Alaafin Prepares To Release Supreme Court Ruling After Ooni’s Ultimatum

Fresh indications emerged on Wednesday that the palace of the Alaafin of Oyo, Oba Akeem Owoade, was preparing to release the Supreme Court judgment, which it said affirmed the Alaafin’s exclusive right to confer chieftaincy titles across Yorubaland.

Naija News reports that this comes after the expiration of the 48-hour ultimatum issued to the Ooni of Ife, Oba Enitan Ogunwusi.

According to Punch, the development followed a series of meetings held by the Alaafin with palace chiefs in Oyo town to deliberate on the way forward.

Recall that on Monday, the Alaafin’s media aide, Bode Durojaiye, had demanded that the Ooni revoke the Okanlomo of Yorubaland title conferred on businessman, Dotun Sanusi, within 48 hours. He cited a Supreme Court ruling in defence of the Alaafin’s position.

The Alaafin accused the Ooni of exceeding his authority and breaching the apex court’s pronouncement on who could confer titles bearing the “Yorubaland” designation. According to him, the Ooni’s powers were limited to the former Oranmiyan Local Government Area, now split into Ife Central, Ife North and Ife South.

With the ultimatum now expired, palace sources told Punch that the Alaafin might unveil the Supreme Court judgment to reinforce his position as the paramount ruler of Yorubaland.

On social media, many Nigerians speculated about the “consequences” hinted at by the palace, even as some urged the Alaafin to caution his aide and withdraw the ultimatum.

Amidst the uncertainty, the Atóbaáse of Yorubaland, Babajide Agunbiade, stated that the Alaafin retains historical and political supremacy among the Yoruba. He advised the monarch to consider legal action to reassert his authority.

In an open letter, Agunbiade emphasised that while the Ooni was revered as the custodian of Yoruba spiritual heritage, the Alaafin’s role as paramount ruler was indisputable.

Agunbiade traced the Alaafin’s authority to the Oyo Empire, whose influence once extended across present-day Yorubaland, Dahomey, Offa and parts of Kogi State. He described the recent action of the Ooni as “an attempt to undermine the authority and tradition of the Alaafin.”

Agunbiade wrote, “As the paramount ruler of the Oyo Empire, which historically spanned vast territories including present-day Yorubaland, Dahomey, Offa, and parts of Kogi State, the Alaafin’s jurisdiction and authority are rooted in tradition and law. The issuance of Yoruba-wide titles is a prerogative reserved for the Alaafin, as the Emperor and ruler of the Yoruba people.

“This position has been reinforced through various judicial pronouncements, culminating in affirmation by the Supreme Court of Nigeria. The Alaafin’s role as the paramount authority in Yoruba land is not merely a matter of tradition but is also grounded in legal precedent. This is not just a matter of personal prestige but also of preserving the cultural heritage and traditions of the Yoruba people.”

But a legal practitioner, Pelumi Olajengbesi, countered that no Supreme Court judgment or constitutional instrument granted the Alaafin exclusive pan-Yoruba authority.

He said, “With the greatest respect, the oft-cited Supreme Court decision that purportedly vested Alaafin authority now exaggerated must be properly confined to its facts. Judicial pronouncements are case-specific, and no ratio decidendi of that Court has ever declared the Alaafin the sole custodian of Yoruba legitimacy. No statute in any Yoruba-speaking state vests exclusive authority in the Alaafin to confer titles of pan-Yoruba significance, and the Court cannot by judicial fiat extend such jurisdiction.

“The law is clear, history is unambiguous, and jurisprudence is settled. The Ooni of Ife has not usurped power; he has exercised it intra vires—lawfully, historically, and culturally. He remains the ancestral father of the Yoruba nation, and his competence to confer honours symbolic of unity is beyond reproach.”

Olajengbesi urged that the Alaafin be advised appropriately, noting that Ile-Ife was universally recognised as the cradle of the Yoruba.

“Every student of Yoruba history knows, tradition and scholarship unanimously affirm Ile-Ife as the cradle of existence of the Yoruba people, the primordial seat where Oduduwa, progenitor of the race, laid the foundation of legitimacy from which all kingdoms, including Oyo, derived their authority.

“As a lawyer, I find no legal, historical, or moral defect in the Ooni’s conferment of the title Okanlomo of Oodua on Chief Dotun Sanusi, an illustrious Yoruba son. On the contrary, it is a timely reminder that while empires rise and fall, the foundation of Yoruba identity, the Ile-Ife and the Ooni, remain timeless, indivisible, and unimpeachable. The Alaafin of Oyo should be properly advised,” Olajengbesi added.